Crimes against humanity concern acts committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population that harm not only their immediate victims but humanity as a whole. In Almonacid Arellano v. Chile, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights emphasized that such crimes violate fundamental values of the international community and are prohibited by international law. Similarly, M. Cherif Bassiouni argues that they constitute international crimes because they threaten interests and values shared by humanity, making their prevention and punishment a concern of the international community rather than solely a domestic matter.
The International Law Commission’s Draft Articles on Prevention and Punishment of Crimes Against Humanity reflect the international community’s interest in their prevention and punishment, also expressed through obligations erga omnes. Leila Nadya Sadat links crimes against humanity to the laws of humanity and the dictates of public conscience, whose fundamental character supports understanding the prohibition of crimes against humanity as a jus cogens norm.
The non-derogable character of certain rights implicated by these crimes is grounded in international human rights law. Articles 4 and 27 of the American Convention on Human Rights establish that certain core rights, including the rights to life and recognition of juridical personality, may not be suspended during emergencies. Similarly, Article 4 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights identifies rights that remain protected under such circumstances. Enforced disappearance is particularly grave because it simultaneously affects several fundamental rights protected by the international human rights system.
Article 7 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court provides the contemporary definition of crimes against humanity, although the concept predates the Statute and has evolved through customary international law and international jurisprudence. It includes murder, extermination, enslavement, deportation, torture, rape, persecution, enforced disappearance, and other inhumane acts committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against a civilian population and with knowledge of the attack.
The Nuremberg Trials first prosecuted atrocities on the premise that certain crimes offend humanity as a whole. Although initially linked to wartime contexts, the jurisprudence of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) and the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) confirmed that crimes against humanity may also be committed in peacetime. In Tadić, the ICTY held that an armed conflict is not required; Kunarac developed the treatment of sexual violence as a crime against humanity; and Akayesu recognized rape, in certain circumstances, as both genocide and a crime against humanity.
Enforced Disappearance and the Inter-American System
Enforced disappearance has a continuing character, reflected in Article 8(1)(b) of the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance, which provides that any limitation period must commence when the offence ceases, taking into account its continuous nature. Sexual and gender-based violence, persecution on political, racial, ethnic, cultural, or gender grounds, and apartheid may also form part of systematic attacks against civilians. Non-state actors, including organized armed groups or criminal structures exercising territorial control, may commit crimes against humanity when they possess the required organization and systematicity.
The Inter-American Convention on Forced Disappearance of Persons establishes obligations for States in the region, including the absolute prohibition of enforced disappearance and the non-applicability of statutes of limitation. The Convention against Torture is also relevant, as torture may constitute a crime against humanity when committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population. The suffering caused by enforced disappearance to victims and their relatives was recognized by the United Nations Human Rights Committee in Quinteros v. Uruguay and subsequently by the Inter-American Court in Blake v. Guatemala, Trujillo Oroza v. Bolivia, and Radilla Pacheco v. Mexico. Additional Protocols I and II to the Geneva Conventions protect civilians in armed conflicts, while the American Convention on Human Rights and Inter-American jurisprudence recognize enforced disappearance as a multiple and continuing violation of fundamental rights.
Nieto Navia, former President of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, argues that in enforced disappearance cases State responsibility may arise from the failure to prevent, investigate, and punish such acts, even when the direct perpetrators cannot be identified as State agents. Distinct from individual criminal responsibility for crimes against humanity, this jurisprudence developed standards of State responsibility under the American Convention on Human Rights. Under Article 1(1), a State that knows of a pattern of serious human rights violations and fails to act breaches its obligation to ensure protected rights. In Velásquez Rodríguez v. Honduras, the Court clarified that domestic prohibitions, institutional lack of information, or the absence of explicit orders do not absolve the State when disappearances form part of a systematic practice it failed to prevent. The principle of effet utile therefore requires interpreting the Convention to ensure effective human rights protection and access to justice.
Contemporary Challenges in Latin America
In March 2026, the UN Committee on Enforced Disappearances decided, pursuant to Article 34 of the Convention, to bring the situation in Mexico to the attention of the UN General Assembly. The decision followed the Committee’s assessment of information indicating a persistent structural pattern of disappearances, insufficient State responses, ineffective searches and investigations, near-total impunity, and inadequate guarantees for victims. Article 34 applies where information appears to contain well-founded indications that enforced disappearance is being practised on a widespread or systematic basis.
In Gomes Lund et al. (“Guerrilha do Araguaia”) v. Brazil (2010), the Inter-American Court held that enforced disappearance is a multiple and continuing violation until the victim’s fate is determined and the facts clarified. The systematic disappearance of political opponents during the Brazilian dictatorship formed part of a pattern of State repression characterized by denial of information, obstruction of investigations, and persistent impunity. The Court reaffirmed that States cannot invoke amnesty laws, statutes of limitation, or equivalent measures to prevent the investigation and punishment of enforced disappearances.
Other countries in the region face patterns of violence that raise questions regarding the possible existence of widespread or systematic attacks against civilians. In Ecuador, the expansion of organized criminal groups has been associated with patterns of killings, intimidation, and violence against civilian populations in territories under their influence, raising concerns about conduct that may fall within some of the acts enumerated in Article 7 of the Rome Statute, particularly murder and other inhumane acts. Reports from the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights have identified concerns regarding the impact of this violence on civilian populations. In Colombia, despite the peace agreement with the FARC, serious violations continue to be reported, including killings of social leaders, forced displacement, massacres, and threats against communities, which may be relevant when assessing the existence of widespread or systematic attacks against civilians. In Venezuela, reports of the UN Independent International Fact-Finding Mission have identified patterns of state repression, arbitrary detention, torture, persecution, and extrajudicial executions, conduct that may correspond to several acts listed under Article 7 of the Rome Statute and that, according to those reports, may amount to crimes against humanity.
Lessons from Latin America: Accountability and Impunity
A first lesson is that impunity is not inevitable. The experiences of Argentina, Chile, Peru, Guatemala, and other States demonstrate that accountability processes may be pursued even decades after the commission of atrocities. In Argentina, the reopening of criminal proceedings following the annulment of the Full Stop (Punto Final) and Due Obedience (Obediencia Debida) laws enabled the prosecution of numerous individuals responsible for crimes committed during the military dictatorship. In Chile, investigations and prosecutions concerning violations committed during the Pinochet regime continued decades after the democratic transition, reaffirming the enduring duty to investigate grave human rights violations. In Peru, accountability efforts related to cases such as Barrios Altos and La Cantuta, together with the findings of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, contributed to challenging patterns of impunity arising from the internal armed conflict. In Guatemala, accountability efforts related to cases such as Plan de Sánchez Massacre v. Guatemala demonstrated both the possibilities and limitations of transitional justice processes in deeply polarized societies. Criminal prosecutions, truth-seeking initiatives, and the reopening of previously closed cases illustrate that the passage of time does not extinguish the obligation to investigate and punish crimes against humanity. This regional experience has reinforced the principle that such crimes are not subject to ordinary limitation periods and that victims retain their rights to truth, justice, and reparation.
A second lesson concerns the incompatibility between amnesties and international obligations arising from serious human rights violations. Latin America has played a decisive role in the development of international standards rejecting legal mechanisms that perpetuate impunity. This evolution is particularly reflected in Gelman v. Uruguay, where the Inter-American Court reaffirmed that States cannot invoke amnesty laws or other domestic measures to avoid their obligations to investigate, prosecute, and punish serious human rights violations. The Court further emphasized that democratic legitimacy or majority support cannot justify impunity for crimes that violate fundamental norms of international law. This regional contribution has become an influential reference in global accountability debates.
A third lesson is the central importance of truth and historical memory. Truth commissions established in Argentina, Chile, Guatemala, Peru, and more recently Colombia demonstrated that accountability extends beyond criminal punishment. By documenting patterns of violence, recognizing victims, and preserving historical memory, institutions such as the Commission for Historical Clarification in Guatemala, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in Peru, and the Commission for the Clarification of Truth, Coexistence and Non-Repetition in Colombia contributed to public acknowledgment of past abuses and the construction of guarantees of non-repetition. The Latin American experience demonstrates that truth-seeking mechanisms and criminal prosecutions should be understood as complementary rather than competing forms of accountability.
A fourth lesson concerns the legal development of standards relating to enforced disappearance. Latin America played a pioneering role in recognizing enforced disappearance as a multiple and continuing violation of human rights. The experiences of countries such as Honduras, Guatemala, Peru, Mexico, and Colombia significantly influenced the evolution of international norms concerning truth, search obligations, criminal investigation, and victims’ rights. The resulting jurisprudence has shaped contemporary international standards on accountability for disappearances and continues to influence international bodies and domestic courts. Few regions have contributed as significantly to the development of legal standards on enforced disappearance as Latin America, whose jurisprudence has become a global reference point in this field.
A fifth lesson is that crimes against humanity are not confined to military dictatorships or traditional armed conflicts. Contemporary challenges in Mexico, Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Haiti, and Nicaragua illustrate how widespread or systematic attacks against civilian populations may emerge in contexts involving organized crime, institutional fragility, political repression, or complex forms of violence. These realities highlight the need to adapt accountability mechanisms to evolving patterns of victimization while preserving fundamental guarantees under international law.
Taken together, these experiences demonstrate that Latin America has become a laboratory of accountability whose successes and failures have significantly influenced international law. The region illustrates both the transformative potential of truth, justice, and reparations mechanisms and the persistent challenges posed by impunity, institutional weakness, and political resistance. Its experience therefore offers valuable lessons for contemporary efforts to prevent and punish crimes against humanity worldwide.
Accountability, Impunity, and the Way Forward
In this scenario, several solution mechanisms have been developed in international law to address patterns of systematic violence and crimes against humanity, especially when States show unwillingness or inability to act. These include reinforced international monitoring mechanisms such as fact-finding missions and special procedures; transitional justice mechanisms such as truth commissions, comprehensive reparation programs, and institutional reforms; the exercise of universal jurisdiction in domestic courts; and cooperation with the International Criminal Court, whether through state referrals or decisions by UN bodies. Together, these mechanisms seek to close protection gaps that allow the persistence of crimes such as enforced disappearance and other acts constituting crimes against humanity.
The relevance of this category for human rights is profound. Its prosecution contributes to guaranteeing victims’ rights to truth, justice, and reparation, and strengthens historical memory and guarantees of non-repetition. It also limits the impunity of state and non-state actors and reinforces the absolute prohibition of practices that constitute grave and systematic violations of human dignity. However, significant challenges remain, including instances of non-cooperation with the International Criminal Court, particularly failures by some States to execute arrest warrants issued by the Court, as illustrated by the Al Bashir case. Political pressures affecting international criminal investigations also continue to pose challenges to the effective administration of international justice. Additional difficulties include evidentiary obstacles in contexts of mass violence and the emergence of new forms of criminality, such as digital repression, mass surveillance, and the use of technologies to control civilian populations.
The Latin American experience demonstrates that accountability is neither automatic nor irreversible. Significant advances in criminal prosecution, truth commissions, reparations programmes, and judicial protection coexist with persistent patterns of impunity and emerging forms of violence. The region therefore offers important lessons for the international community: amnesties cannot prevail over fundamental rights, enforced disappearances generate continuing obligations of investigation, victims’ rights must remain central to accountability processes, and justice may remain achievable even decades after atrocities have been committed. At the same time, the persistence of new forms of violence reminds us that accountability mechanisms must continuously adapt to changing realities while preserving their commitment to truth, justice, and human dignity.
Crimes against humanity thus remain an essential legal category for addressing the gravest atrocities and ensuring accountability for those responsible. Their prosecution contributes to combating impunity, recognizing victims’ rights to truth, justice, and reparation, and may also have a deterrent effect on future violations. Their evolution demonstrates the capacity of international law to adapt to new realities, while also highlighting the need to strengthen mechanisms of investigation, international cooperation, and victim protection. At the same time, international criminal law cannot by itself address the structural causes of human rights violations, which require broader political, institutional, and social responses. Despite these limitations, in a world where state, para-state, and organized criminal violence persists, the effective application of this legal framework remains indispensable for accountability, victim redress, and the protection of human dignity.

